top of page

Choosing Between a Professional Bookkeeper and an In-House Employee

  • Writer: Jenny Marie
    Jenny Marie
  • 2 days ago
  • 2 min read

Many small business owners think they should hire an employee for bookkeeping tasks. I wanted to explore this topic to discuss the pros and cons.


Smiling woman sitting at a desk in an office, wearing a blue blouse. A keyboard, monitor, and paperwork are on the glass surface. Bright and professional atmosphere.

I will outline the benefits of each option for comparison. In certain situations, employing an in-house bookkeeper may offer more advantages, though it may not always be the most cost-effective choice. However, in these specific cases, the advantages tend to outweigh the disadvantages.


IN-HOUSE BOOKKEEPER

Pros

  • For larger companies with a high volume of transactions requiring daily management for reporting purposes, it is advisable to employ an in-house bookkeeper. Think 2000-3000 transactions a month and managers rely on daily reports as opposed to weekly or monthly.


  • Many businesses assign additional responsibilities to the individual, making the payroll cost more justifiable. However, this often means the individual may not be a professional in bookkeeping and could become distracted when handling financial data.


  • If a business operates using paper-based systems and is not inclined to transition to digital operations, employing an in-house bookkeeper would be more appropriate. However, it is important to consider that we are increasingly becoming a digital society. Paper records can lead to misplaced items, and accessing these records remotely is not possible.


  • SALARY: You are looking at about $52,000 (including payroll taxes) and this is an entry-level person.


Paper records can lead to misplaced items, and accessing these records remotely is not possible.

OUTSOURCED BOOKKEEPERS

Pros


  • Professionals frequently possess extensive experience and knowledge due to their work with a diverse range of clients. This expertise is particularly beneficial when troubleshooting. Additionally, they employ specialized methods for organizing data, which can be more advantageous than hiring an entry-level individual who may be unfamiliar with your specific type of business.


  • Their fees are determined by the work and value provided, rather than the number of hours spent appearing busy. Additionally, these fees are significantly more cost-effective compared to hiring a part-time or full-time employee.


  • The perspective and level of responsibility are often more closely aligned with those of a business owner.


  • BONUS: Collaborating with the right professional can enhance financial workflows, thereby increasing profitability. We provide this service. We can also help turn manual systems into digital ones.


  • BONUS: If your outsourced bookkeeper also provides Financial Strategy services or Fractional CFO Consulting, this adds significantly more value than a typical employee. Having someone who can identify red flags and analyze your business to develop growth strategies offers advantages that far exceed those of a regular employee. (we offer this service)


  • COST: Bookkeeping + Financial Strategy may cost $1000 / month equalling $12,000. Compare that to an entry-level employee. It's a $40K difference.


Having someone who can identify red flags and analyze your business to develop growth strategies offers advantages that far exceed those of a regular employee.

If you would like help determining whether it makes more sense to hire someone in-house or out, we can help you.


Schedule a Free Consult, CONTACT US!




Comments


bottom of page